Part 1:
It was difficult to engage in a full on conversation without speaking or writing. When i was asked simple questions it was easy to respond by facial expressions, head or shoulder movement, and hand signals. I found myself in a blank stare when asked complex questions. My partner mostly laughed at me. She also began to talk slowly which was pointless but she thought it was helping. The speaking culture would have the advantage in communicating complex ideas because they can explain them throughly. The speaking culture would have a "better than you" attitude because they feel smarter. I took ASL in high school and had to pretend to be deaf in public for a project. When i went places I had to communicate with basic hand signals, or writing.
Part 2:
I am very enthusiastic with my hands when I communicate. So, when I started this I sat on my hands. I caught myself nodding my head a few times, and giving facial expressions in the 15 minutes. My partner was mostly bored by me because it was like talking to a robot. I was monotone and not lively. The different ways we say words and expressions we make are important in our language technique of communication. I don't think there are people who have trouble reading body language, unless however you are blind. It is beneficial to understand body language so that you can communicate properly. I honestly can't think of an environment condition where it would be good not to read body language.
"She also began to talk slowly which was pointless but she thought it was helping."
ReplyDeleteLove that comment. Kind of like an tourist will speak more slowly and loudly to native resident who doesn't speak their language, as if that would help.
I would have liked for you to expand upon the experiment you did pretending to be deaf in high school. Did you notice being treated differently during the experiment? If so, why?
Good catch noting the problems those who are blind may have reading body language, but remember that non-spoken language also includes changes in voice (volume, inflection, etc) and you don't need your eyes to pick up on that. My guess is that people who are blind are much better than us at picking up the tiniest alterations in spoken communication.
Good post.
Yes, in my "Deaf for a day" assignment I was treated very differently. Most people were impatient and frustrated towards me. They had very put out attitudes. Other were very sweet, but maybe too sweet and treated me like a baby.
ReplyDeleteDuring the first part of the experience my partner laughed at me a lot too and had a similar reaction to the second part. There is one thing I do not agree with which is the statement " I don't think there are people who have trouble reading body language..." because (since you read and commented on my post you already saw this)autistic people have a hard time and there are even some people that just have a hard time understanding body language. Other than that I really enjoyed your post.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the response, Keely.
ReplyDeleteMy partner reacted the same way, by speaking louder and at a much slower pace, as though it would make some kind of difference. Although she knew I could hear, obviously... and that this was nothing more than an experiment, she did it naturally without thinking.
ReplyDelete